Group: Specific Diets & Nutrition

Created: 2012/01/01, Members: 104, Messages: 22775

With so many diets and nutritional plans out there, you can get lost. Find out what works best for others and share your experiences!

Join group

Atkins diet?

mysignal
mysignal
Posts: 1
Joined: 2002/01/26
United States
2002/02/01, 03:00 PM
Hi! I'm new here and wanted to know if anyone has tried the Atkins diet and whether or not they was successful with it? My father and I are similar body types (really overweight) and he has lost almost 100 lbs. over the last year with it. I understand that many people don't recommend it because of it's encouragement to eat foods high in fat, no carbs, etc. Anyone got extra info?
rev8ball
rev8ball
Posts: 3,081
Joined: 2001/12/27
United States
2002/02/01, 05:20 PM
first off: welcome aboard! never hesitate to ask us anything.

there have been numerous studies recently (i'm looking for the citations as we speak) that suggest that type of diet for the average person is not very healthy for several reasons:

It is meant for short-term. staying on that high of a protein intake and that low of a carb intake with little or no exercise could have some ramifications on the kidneys and liver. they are part of the system that helps the body with ph balance as well as insulin/sugar balance. over extended time, this type of habit could induce some damage to them. also, this type of diet, if not done carefully, can easily increase the bad cholesterol level as well as dangerous triglycerides.

also, people who otherwise wouldnt try any diet because it may be too much work tend to use atkins type diets as an excuse to eat as much fat as they can possibly intake, again defeating the purpose.

basically, it comes to this: your body needs proteins, carbs and fats to function, period. the weight problems come not from any one of those, but from a high increase in overall caloric intake with an dramatic decrease in caloric usage.
Philia2
Philia2
Posts: 4,078
Joined: 2001/10/19
France
2002/02/02, 03:26 AM
Here you go. Michael you said the words.

I don't like the Atkins diet as well (because of the too low carb intake and too much fat -Ketogenic diet)

Weight loss is a question about calorie intake and how many calories you burn. Nothing else.