Group: Beginners to Exercise

Created: 2012/01/01, Members: 970, Messages: 18927

Share and offer advice to beginners to the fitness world!

Join group

Elliptical Trainer or a Treadmill?

kmac1
kmac1
Posts: 1
Joined: 2006/08/26
Canada
2006/09/03, 01:06 PM
I want to buy one of them but im not sure which one. I want to tone my body but not lose weight. Which would be better for me?
msmogreen
msmogreen
Posts: 717
Joined: 2006/04/22
United States
2006/09/03, 06:24 PM
They are both good options for cardiovascular health. Personally, if I was going to invest in one or the other, I think the treadmill is more versatile and less monotonous (i.e., you can walk, run or jog or do a combo of the three). For toning you want weights.
Carivan
Carivan
Posts: 8,542
Joined: 2002/01/20
Canada
2006/09/03, 08:09 PM
Like MSM stated they are both good for cardio health. The elliptical is not as hard on the joints as is a treadmill. A good quality eliptacle will be programable, and also have manual settings just like a good quality treadmill. One burns more calories with on an eliptical machine verses a treadmill.

To answer your original question on which will tone your body more, I would have to say neither. These are not sculpting machines. To tone your body you would need to do resistance training with Bands or weights.



--------------
Scales are for dead weight: We are not dead yet!
Still trying to find out how to do the Hollywood Free Press.

Ivan

Montreal Canada