Group: Women's Club

Created: 2011/12/31, Members: 528, Messages: 10844

A place for women to gather and share experiences, advice and information amongst themselves.

Join group

Meal Replacement or Protein Shake?

TheDancer
TheDancer
Posts: 6
Joined: 2002/10/28
United States
2002/11/22, 08:25 PM
Does anybody know what the difference is? How are they each used? And which is better for losing weight?

Thanks!
bb1fit
bb1fit
Posts: 11,105
Joined: 2001/06/30
United States
2002/11/22, 10:19 PM
Protein shakes are simply as the name implies, protein only, or very close to it depending on the brand. MRP's are more designed as a meal,containing protein, a decent amount of carbohydrates, and maybe even some fats, plus vitamins and minerals, thus the name meal replacement powders. To use them to your best advantage, a protein shake will do you well immediately post training. MRP's will serve you well throughout the day, either as the name implies, replacing a meal, or just as nourishment in a pinch when you need some nutrition. For strictly losing weight, MRP's can be very helpful in that each is only about 250-300 calories, and can be used in place of a meal. I would not use them extensively, meaning in place of too many meals. Just one or two will do. Hope this helps.
effalunt
effalunt
Posts: 333
Joined: 2002/10/17
Canada
2002/11/27, 12:29 AM
Just noticing what you call yourself. I'm a former dancer, wondering exactly what you mean by your name.

--------------
Think you can or think you can't; either way you're right--Goethe
TheDancer
TheDancer
Posts: 6
Joined: 2002/10/28
United States
2002/12/01, 07:10 PM
I didn't really mean anything by it other than I love to dance. And if I'd been blessed with the body and talent of a dancer that's what I would have done. What kind of dancer were you?
effalunt
effalunt
Posts: 333
Joined: 2002/10/17
Canada
2002/12/02, 12:11 AM
I did ballet, jazz, lyrical. I was never pro, really I was just average in terms of talent-but I was so passionate about it that it didn't matter. I still using lots of dance and pointe work as part of my fitness program. I still do love to go to a good club, especially latin, and cut loose with my friends. The problem seems to be finding a man to dance with who won't step on my feet. Dancing makes me feel free and feminine, -it's so amazing!

--------------
Think you can or think you can't; either way you're right--Goethe